Article
Early Active Vector Adjustable Skin Traction (EAVAST) for phalangeal fractures of the hand
Search Medline for
Authors
Published: | February 6, 2020 |
---|
Outline
Text
Objectives/Interrogation: The study aimed to determine the efficacy and outcomes of EAVAST in the treatment of middle and proximal phalangeal fractures in comparison with surgical management.
Methods: A retrospective cohort study has reviewed the outcomes of middle and proximal finger phalangeal fractures managed by EAVAST (n= 54) compared to surgical cases (n=47) in a public hospital over a 3-year period. Age range was 13-77 years. Outcome measures utilized included total active motion (TAM), clinical outcome measures (Belsky criteria), and grip strength. Main method of treatment was used for analysis grouping.
Results and Conclusions: In finger fractures at eight weeks post fracture, a mean 230o TAM (95% CI range 90o-285o, SD 34.2) was achieved with traction (n=54) compared to mean 198o TAM (95% CI range 50o-286o, SD 54.8) for surgical cases (n=47). The results were statistically significant (p<0.001). In the traction group, results were excellent in 18%, good in 41% and poor in 33% cases by Belsky's criteria. In the surgical group excellent results were present in 9%, good in 28% and poor in 50%.
There were no significant differences in grip strength between the traction and surgical groups.
The groups were similar in age and handedness, the traction group received more comminuted fractures (61%) than the surgical group (43%). ANOVA regression analysis showed age to be statistically significant in effect on data variation (p=0.026). Intra-articular classification (p=0.08), comminution (p=0.91), and location of fracture (p=0.41) were not statistically significant.
The traction group had less complications (5%) than the surgical group (22%).
This study shows EAVAST may provide improved TAM and clinical outcomes compared to surgery with less complications and should be considered an effective option for the management of middle and proximal phalangeal fractures of the hand.