Artikel
Fulfillment of patients’ expectations for osteosynthesis in complex proximal tibial fractures
Suche in Medline nach
Autoren
Veröffentlicht: | 25. Oktober 2022 |
---|
Gliederung
Text
Objectives: Surgical treatment of proximal tibial fractures is often associated with complications and postoperative limitations in knee motion. Unrealistic patient expectations of the operation may lead to dissatisfaction with the surgical outcome despite successful surgery. In a previous study it was shown that patients have unrealistic high expectations of surgical intervention in terms of return to mobility and full range of motion of the knee joint. In this follow-up study fulfillment of these expectations was evaluated.
Methods: From 2017-2018, n=114 patients with complex proximal tibial fracture type AO/OTA-B and C were prospectively enrolled at three level A trauma centers. Prior to surgery, expectations were assessed with the Hospital for Special Surgery-Knee Surgery Expectations Score (HSS-KSE) and a 10-item survey regarding return to sports/work/pain relief. These surveys showed high expectations regarding the different parameters. In a follow-up study regarding fulfillment of these expectations every single patient was confronted with their individual expectations (ranged 0=Expectation was not fulfilled up to 2= Expectation was completely fullfilled). This follow-up was completed by 49 patients up to now. (n=22m, n=27f, n= 22 AO-B, n=27 AO-C). P<0.05 was assumed as being statistically significant.
Results and conclusion: Regarding fulfillment of HSS parameters in most patients at least "partial fulfillment" was reached. HSS parameters reached 1.16- 1.78 points (mean). The parameter "kneeling" performed worst in both groups. The parameter "psychological well-being" performed best. 31 patients (63%) reported that they would rate their operated knee as "A completely normal knee joint with complete improvement" or "An almost normal knee joint with good improvement". 77% of the patients were at least satisfied with the results of their surgery and 71% were at least satisfied if they had to live for the rest of their life with exactly the knee joint pain. No statistical difference was detected between AO-B and AO-C.
Patients' expectations prior to surgery are high and partly unrealistic compared to the literature. Nevertheless most of the patients are satisfied with their overall results of the surgery afterwards although their peroperative expectations do not fully meet their postoperative fulfillment. In the context of patient satisfaction and the ratio "better in better out", it seems reasonable to better emphasize postoperative goals in order to improve patient satisfaction.